We can't stress enough: BOOK EARLY! We recommend the following options.
Old-Town Homer
Any place in Old-Town is a short walk from the wedding and a few restaurants, cafes, and bars.
Suites by the Beach is a nice three-room bed and breakfast located above the wonderful Two Sisters bakery.
Homer Seaside Cottages has three cabins that sleep 6-8 people. Special bonus: owned by Jewel's aunt!
Old Town Bed & Breakfast up a charmingly slanted flight of stairs are three rooms, one with private bath, two with a shared bathroom.
Bluffview Lodge at the Driftwood Inn a big ol' house that includes 5 private deluxe suites, rented individually.
Pioneer Inn not actually in old-town, but a 10 minute walk away. No frills motel.
Outside of Old-Town
Car required.
Homer Inn & Spa has four suites, a jacuzzi, and spa services. (A three minute drive from Old-Town.)